Email Conversation Exchange

-


A conversation space for members of the Military History Society of New South Wales
To post, reply or comment please email: president@militaryhistorynsw.com.au

> From David Wilson on 2021-07-29 18:58

A quick heads-up on this WFA lecture on Mont St Quentin to be given online by Julian Whippy who has an excellent reputation in the guiding community. 

If I’ve done my search on the time zone clock correctly then 2000hr on Mon 2 Aug (UK time) is 0600hr on Tues morning for us here in the Antipodes (Sydney time).  A bit early for me, I think. However, the advertising notes also say it will be available later on YouTube which is probably where I’ll catch it when it goes up on that platform.

https://www.westernfrontassociation.com/events/online-a-fine-feat-of-war-the-taking-of-mont-st-quentin-1918-by-julian-whippy/

 

> From David Wilson on on 2021-07-22

We did something like this years ago (referring to Royal Australian Historical Society initiative called "Researching Soldiers In Your Local Community"), see link to Ku-ring-gai Historical Society's "Rallying The Troops" books about local men who served in the Great War:

https://www.khs.org.au/large-books/


> From Colin Kay on 2021-07-09 14:16:

There is one stubble difference, at the end of the day it was the Boers who surrendered. 

Not the English who ran away, I had this discussion with my American OC in SVN, he felt that we had used far too many troops in Malaya; again at the end of the ride the Min Yun were hiding in Thailand and the Yanks ran away.

> From David Wilson on 2021-07-09 12:39:
An interesting article and comparison which immediately grabbed my attention. I've been preparing a talk for WEA Sydney on Dien Bien Phu 1954 and in one of the references I used, it said that Lt Gen Navarre (the Theatre Commander in Indochina) had presented his 'Navarre Plan' to the French Govt in July 1953 where he proposed an army of 500,000 men to regain control of the Indochina colony, then comprising Vietnam, Laos and Cambodia. This army would be made up of:
·        French nationals (regular army);
·        French colonials (regulars from North Africa and West African colonies);
·        Foreign Legion (regulars - mainly displaced WW2 veterans from 'all over Europe');
·        Indochinese nationals (regulars in 3 x national armies)
·        Indochinese militias (locally-recruited and based nationals, i.e. Montagnards etc) 
None of this ever came to pass, of course, which is why the French suffered a series of tactical defeats across Indochina in 1953 and 1954 by the Viet Minh culminating in the battle of Dien Bien Phu which ended on 6/7 May 54 with that garrison being overrun.  Six months later the French were out of Indochina for good. 
I can't find the exact reference to the 500,000 troops demanded by Navarre – I think it's somewhere in Martin Windrow's massive 700+ page, but excellent history "The Last Valley" but I haven't got the page number.

 > From Frances Cairns on 2021-07-09 10:44:
an interesting article and it would make a good talk if someone could take it on.  

> From John McKeown on 2021-07-09 10:32:

Interesting article! Perhaps Kitchener's ruthlessness in rounding up civilians and thus denying

sustenance to the Boer fighters made that campaign simpler than the more "civilised" 
 
Afghanistan war. Regards John

> From Bob Guest on 2021-07-08 09:31:

The comparison with the Boer War is interesting: 

http://www.chrisash.co.za/2021/07/07/i-need-500000-men/


 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Bathurst RSL Letter on Bathurst Boer War Memorial - Lt Peter Handcock

-
Image
Lt Peter Handcock O n Anzac Day this year journalist Peter FitzSimons wrote an article published in the Sydney Morning Herald calling for the removal of the name of Lieutenant Peter Handcock from the Bathurst, New South Wales, Boer War Memorial on the ground that he was a convicted war criminal, for which he was executed by firing squad alongside Lieutenant Harry "Breaker" Morant  in South Africa on 27 February 1902. Handcock was a Bathurst district local. James Unkles is an author, former naval reserve officer, military and civilian lawyer, and campaigner for a pardon for Morant, Handcock and the third convicted man, George Witton. On 30 May 2021 James posted a response to FitzSimons on his website. The response notes that on 4 May 2021 the Bathurst Sub-Branch of the RSL wrote to Bathurst Regional Council, which controls the monument, opposing the removal of any names from the Memorial. A copy of the letter is reproduced below. Bathurst Regional Council has declined to re...
Read more

Second World War Tour 2025: Anzac Day in Athens - Greece and Crete

-
Image
  On the 6 April 1941 the German Army launched its attack against the Greeks on the Metaxas Line and the Imperial Expeditionary Force at Florina. The Allied force was pushed off Greece by 28 April and so began the Battle of Crete. Join our memorial tour lead by Lt-Colonel Ron Lyons (retd), Vice President, Military History Society of NSW, in conjunction with Battlefield History Tours, to Greece and Crete visiting the battlefields where the 6th Division and the New Zealand Division confronted the German Army. This is a special tour developed for the very special purpose that we hope will, in a small way, ensure that this part of Australian and New Zealand history is not forgotten. As we visit the battle sites, each with an informative briefing, we will meet the local dignitaries who maintain our military heritage and pay our respects at the resting places of our fallen. ABOUT BATTLEFIELD HISTORY TOURS www.battlefieldhistorytours.com.au Battlefield History Tours is one of Australia’s ...
Read more

Statement on the Vandalisation of Public Monuments and War Memorials

-
Image
  STATEMENT ON THE VANDALISATION OF PUBLIC MONUMENTS AND WAR MEMORIALS The following statement was adopted by the Council of the Military History Society of New South Wales at their meeting on Monday, 28 October 2024: As a body dedicated to preserving and honouring our state’s military heritage, the Military History of New South Wales is disturbed by continuing instances of defacement, vandalism and misuse of historical public monuments, including war and veterans memorials. Acts of physical destruction as a means of political expression should be condemned unreservedly. These attacks represent an infringement of community rights. They are an illegitimate substitute for the democratic processes by which these monuments are properly managed with broad popular consent. This is true even if controversy surrounds the monument in question. In the case of war memorials, the attacks dishonour the sacrifice, and insult the relatives, of those who gave their lives for the precious freed...
Read more